In the world of sport a new force is emerging. One that no doubtably requires skill but is E-sport a legitimate player in the world of competitive sports? I hope not…
Listen to the my podcast about the debate over the legitimacy of E-sports
Sport holds such a special place in my life. It is my career, my past time and my passion. From being a young lad in small town New Zealand playing rugby in the winter and cricket in the summer to all over the world as a PE teacher and coach, sport has taught me about myself and those around me. It has helped me learn values that I apply to all areas of my life and helped me ensure that I am healthy physically, mentally and socially.
I also enjoy video gaming. I have always owned the latest console and still play when I have a free moment to myself. I like the ability to switch onto competition quickly in the comfort of my own house. Sitting happily on my favourite chair.
Then if I love sport and enjoy gaming why do I feel so threatened that E-sport is gaining popularity and pushing for more legitimacy in the sporting world? Shouldn’t I love the fact that something I love and some thing I like have morphed together? After completing my podcast and discussing the topic with some of my friends I have it figured out. I don’t like the fact that E-sports are trying to get on par with “real sports” and here is why.
- Lack of physical output
One of the major reasons that I love sport is the buzz you get from being active. If it be completing a 5km or playing a game of basketball you feel good about getting your body moving. My lecturer Ian Culpin from the University of Canterbury always said that “there is joy in movement. Simply moving is joyful” He was right and more people now days know about the release of endorphins when we exercise. They are the feel good chemicals that are released when the body is stressed through exercise. They make you laugh and enjoy yourself simply through movement. Exercise.com suggest that some people need upwards of 30min intense exercise to experience the release of endorphins. This natural high is something I crave when I haven’t been active for awhile. That “good” feeling of accomplishment when you have your heart rate up and your shirt is covered in sweat.
How can we class a E-sports as legitimate if we can’t experience this joyous phenomenon. Others will claim that E-sport has physical components such as fine motor skills and reaction time. However, in my eyes these are not enough to warrant a place in the legitimate sporting real. E-sports will get your heart racing with the outcome of a close match but not due to the intense physical requirement. One study conducted by “The Journal of Pediatrics” found that a 14 year old playing video games will burn only 81 calories in an hour. Compared that with the whooping number of over 250 calories burned when playing football for one hour. The lack of physical exertion is the first reason E-sport is not legit.
- The danger for parents and educators if E-sports is legitimised as a real sport
Mum “Tom you have been inside all day. You need to get out and get some exercise.”
Tom “I have been exercising all day. I have been playing Dota for 3 hours.”
This is something that I am seriously concerned about as an educator. If E-sports is seen on par with other sports then the battle to get kids active more often is going to be tougher than it already is. Some parents will allow gaming all day and others will have an uphill battle justifying that it isn’t. Imagine a world where kids don’t turn up to the local sporting ground to participate for their sports team, but rather turn on their video games and play from the sofa. Playing organised sport as a kid is where you learn so many things about yourself and others. That will be lost if the physical intensities and interactions with others is switched for a video screen.
Im not naive and know that E-sports are on the rise and here to stay. My hope is that it is considered as its own event rather than part of the sporting world. Kids need more excuses now days to be healthy and active rather than legitimise them to being couch potatoes.



